Why You’re Not Getting Interviews Even Though You’re Qualified—and How to Fix It

Listen to the original podcast here

I get it: job hunting can feel like throwing your resume into a black hole. You’re qualified, you’re trying, and yet... no responses. If this sounds familiar, you may be falling into some common (but fixable!) traps that hold applicants back from standing out. Let’s break down why this happens and give you some tips to help you land that interview.

1. Stop Underselling Yourself: Show Off a Little!

Many of us feel awkward talking about our achievements, but underselling yourself only makes recruiters think you’re less experienced than you are. Talking confidently about what you’ve done isn’t bragging; it helps hiring managers see your value.

Pro Tip: Use numbers to highlight achievements on your resume. Instead of “managed a team,” say something like, “led a team of 5 and boosted efficiency by 20%.

2. Location Issues: Will You Relocate?

If you live far from the job, recruiters might skip over your application, especially if they’re not offering relocation packages. Senior positions may be more flexible with remote hires, but entry-level roles tend to favor locals.

Pro Tip: If you’re up for relocating (likely on your own dime), say that on your resume and cover letter to avoid getting filtered out.

3. Lacking Industry-Specific Experience

Some industries and job roles require niche knowledge and connections (think: fashion, beauty, entertainment, finance, tech), and might prefer candidates who do.

Pro Tip: Want to switch industries? Look into certifications or online courses that give you a leg up. In your cover letter, highlight skills that would be valuable across any industry.

4. Your Application is Getting Lost

Applying through job boards? You’re not alone—which is why your resume might be floating in a sea of others. Hundreds of applications flood in, and companies often stop sifting through after they’ve found some good fits, meaning they don’t read yours

Pro Tip: Instead of just applying through job boards, contact hiring managers or team leads via email or on LinkedIn. Let them know you applied and are interested; it shows initiative and makes your name stick out.

5. Beware of Outdated Job Listings

Job boards like Salary.com and Jobgether are notorious for reposting old listings, which wastes time on roles that may not even be open anymore.

Pro Tip: Double-check the job on the company’s website. If it’s outdated or they’ve reposted it a ton, move on. If it redirects to a legit third-party site like Workday, apply there and then reach out directly to a recruiter at the company.

6. The Company Could Be on a Hiring Freeze

Sometimes companies post roles but don’t plan to hire immediately, or they put hiring on pause for budget reasons. Unfortunately, you’ll never know this unless they tell you.

Pro Tip: Send a quick follow-up after a few weeks. It shows interest, keeps your name on their mind, and allows you to ask if the hiring process is still ongoing.

7. Timing Is Everything

If you’re applying after hundreds of others have already done so, the hiring team might not even get to your application.

Pro Tip: Set up alerts for job postings on LinkedIn or other job sites. Applying within the first few days (or hours, if possible) can increase your chances of being seen.

8. Working with Third-Party Recruiters Can Be Hit or Miss

Third-party recruiters aren’t always the best route unless they work directly for the company on a specific role. They’re paid by companies, not candidates, and rightfully prioritize fillinpositions their clients ask them to fill, so getting you a job isn’t a priority.

Pro Tip: When in doubt, go directly through the company’s job portal, especially if you’re unsure if a recruiter is legit. For recruiters specifically hired by the company, though, feel free to use them—they’re plugged into the hiring process.

9. Being Overqualified Can Backfire

If you’re aiming for a junior role despite having loads of experience, hiring managers may worry you’ll get bored or jump ship for something more challenging.

Pro Tip: If you’re intentionally targeting a lower-level job, use your cover letter to explain why. Make it clear what you bring to the role and how you see it fitting into your long-term plans.

10. Salary Expectations Might Be Too High

If a company thinks you’re too expensive, they might assume you’re out of budget before contacting you.

Pro Tip: Research salary ranges for the role beforehand and be honest with yourself about whether it’s truly worth your time. If you’re flexible on salary, be upfront about that during the initial interview.

11. Competition Is Fierce, and the Talent Pool is Strong

You might be up against other well-qualified people who already work there (internal candidates), have niche experience, or simply applied earlier than you.

Pro Tip: Keep applying! Even if you’re up against a strong candidate pool, every application and interview builds experience and increases your chances of finding that perfect fit.

Next-Level Tips for Your Job Search

1. Build Your Network: Follow industry leaders, attend online and in-person events, and join LinkedIn groups—networking often opens doors faster than blindly submitting resumes.

2. Tailor Your Applications: Tweak your resume to match the job description. Keywords from the job listing help you get past Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS).

3. Always Follow Up: A quick follow-up email after applying or after an interview shows you’re serious and keeps you top of mind.

The job search can be exhausting, but understanding these roadblocks and adjusting your approach can make all the difference. Keep refining your applications, follow up consistently, and don’t get discouraged by setbacks—your next opportunity is on the horizon.